Friday, November 30, 2007
Should Religous Beliefs Dictate Stem Cell Legislation?
ARGUING WITH THE CHURCH: Catholic Beliefs to Dictate Stem Cell Program?
by Don C. Reed www.stemcellbattles.com

Religious freedom is a fundamental American right, no matter how foolish
that faith may seem to others. If I wanted to worship goldfish, I have the
legal right to do so, without being persecuted-but do I have the right to
impose Goldfish Worship on others?

My family's faith (though not my own) is Catholic. Should that religion's
beliefs be required of Baptists, Episcopalians, atheists, Muslims,
Presbyterians, Jews, agnostics, Sikhs and Buddhists?

The Catholic Church is trying to force to force its stem cell research
policies onto everyone.

This is not a casual attempt, but a world-wide effort, beginning with the
Vatican, which recently opined that supporting embryonic stem cell research
is an excommunicable offense. Think what that means-that I should literally
be condemned to Hell for all eternity for my opinions on medical research?

To me, that is as nonsensical-and cruel-as the religious belief that
anesthesia in childbirth was against God's wishes, because it said in the
Bible that "In sorrow thou shalt bring forth children."

Personally, I have more faith in God than that. For me, the reason God gave
us a brain is to think and solve problems. But that is my opinion, and I
would not attempt to enshrine it into law.

The reason America separates church and state is because there can never be
agreement on something unprovable. How can God be even described, unless we
can bring Him/Her/It into the room with us? And if we cannot describe God
without arguing, how can we ever hope to agree on religious legislation?

But down through history, the Church has been a power structure, as well as
a source of comfort and wisdom. And when it steps into politics, it must not
be allowed to go unchallenged.

If religious officialdom forces a law, that affects us all. If you drive
into a town where the Churches "persuaded" local officials to require all
stores to close on Sundays, and you need to buy a quart of milk, you are out
of luck.

And if you live in a state or a country-or a world--- where stem cell
research was declared illegal.

In the United Nations, Catholic priests accompanied Bush administration
officials as they attempted to impose a world-wide ban on SCNT (Somatic Cell
Nuclear Transfer, sometimes called therapeutic cloning) an advanced form of
stem cell research.

Nationally, the Catholic Church's and other Religious Right organizations
routinely bully and terrify legislators, utterly controlling the Republican
Party's stem cell policy, preventing the passage of even such a moderate and
mild law as the Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act.

In state after state, the Catholic Church is the center of the anti-research
movement.

In Missouri, the church passed out lawn signs opposing Amendment 2 (which
said Missouri should not be denied any federally-approved medical research),
and let churches be offices for groups which passed out plastic fetuses to
children at county fairs, saying this is what embryonic stem cell research
is all about.

In California, Catholic churches distributed glossy full-color fliers
opposing the science supported by Proposition 71-and every California church
receives anti-embryonic research materials routinely, for the priests to
intone from the pulpit, and for parishioners to take home with them.

In Michigan, the Church mailed 504,000 anti-research CDs (think of the
money-a church which takes a vow of poverty somehow can afford to burn half
a million CDs and postage and padded envelopes for one state mailing alone)
to the homes of Catholic families.

In Texas, meetings of the legislature are held late at night with little or
no public notice-so the Catholic anti-science view can be drummed into the
heads of legislators without opposition.

And now, with the experimental "success" of an alternative stem cell
technique, their campaign moves into high gear.

Led by the Catholic Church, anti-research forces will try to use the
experimental skin cell technique (Induced Pluripotent Stem cells, or IPSc)
to shut down embryonic and SCNT research.

Do I exaggerate?

To see the actual open letter from the New York State Catholic Conference
revealing the Church's intent to control stem cell policy and read the rest
of this article, please go to www.stemcellbattles.com
Don C. Reed

Rayilyn Brown
Board Member AZNPF
Arizona Chapter National Parkinson's Foundation
[log in to unmask]

----------------------------------------------------------------------
To sign-off Parkinsn send a message to: mailto:[log in to unmask]
In the body of the message put: signoff parkinsn