 |
 |
Do we really need this "publication"? I would be interested in hearing what you think this journal would offer that others don't. As a non Shakespearean, I am under the impression that there are more places to publish articles, books, reviews and "notes" on Shakespeare than on any other single topic. Thomas, it sounds as if you have already been able to find an audience for your work, in fact. Don't these opportunities exist for undergraduates who are doing quality work? In fact, if they had work that could be published elsewhere, why would they publish with this Journal? Wouldn't its very name be a stigma? Will this just be a place for students to publish who can't publish elsewhere? In another vein, there are distinct problems with "online" publications when it comes to establishing credentials for anybody. If there is an editorial review process, with established, not to say distinguished, scholars on board, then it will be taken seriously by some. But there are many graduate schools (or tenure committees) that will be skeptical about this as a publishing credit. (Of course, they could judge for themselves with an easily accessible website.) I'm in favor of digital publication, so this isn't meant to be a wet blanket, just the kind of reality check that those of us interested in web publishing have already encountered. Perhaps the advantages of digital outweigh the objections. (I can imagine so). But if you are going to all of the trouble of establishing an online presence that can be taken seriously and be sustained over the longer term, why restrict it to undergraduates? As Jim O'Donnell notes in Avatars of the Word, without paper, publishing, mailing etc. costs, the only real restriction on online publishing is the stamina of the editors. I imagine that students at my institution would be potential contributors here. We require senior theses that are sometimes quite good, but rarely find an audience outside of the committees that grade them. These students do not always... or immediately.. go on to graduate school. As to Susan's comment about being embarrassed by early work.... doesn't this happen all the time? It's easier to take a publication offline than to recall copies of publications though. Obviously this subject has caught our attention. I will be interested to hear how your project proceeds. Amelia Carr Allegheny College Meadville PA 16335