Print

Print


   A cup of black tea a day ...

 ... will keep Parkinson's disease away, so says landmark S'pore study

  Thursday • January 24, 2008

 Alicia Wong
[log in to unmask]

 BLACK, not green tea, helps to ward off Parkinson's disease. 

In a landmark study here, researchers have found that drinking black tea 
reduces the risk of Parkinson's among the Chinese population.

Good news, perhaps, for Singapore's ageing population, which might see the 
number of Parkinson's cases jump two-and-a-half fold by 2030.

The ongoing study, which began 15 years ago, is the first of its kind in Asia 
and one of only a handful worldwide. It is also the first large-scale 
community-based study on diet and nutrition in Singapore. 

Co-led by Dr Koh Woon Puay, an assistant professor from the community, 
occupational and family medicine department of Yong Loo Lin School of 
Medicine in the National University of Singapore (NUS) and Dr Louis Tan, a 
senior consultant neurologist at the National Neuroscience Institute (NNI), 
the study scrutinised the lifestyle and dietary habits of more than 63,000 
Chinese Singaporeans. 

After accounting for lifestyle factors, a "novel finding" was that black tea 
contains ingredients, other than caffeine, that have protective effects, said 
Dr Koh.

Previous studies had revealed the protective effects of caffeine.

The findings showed that having an average of one cup of black tea a day was 
strongly related to a nearly 70-per-cent reduced risk of the disease. When 
adjusted for the caffeine level in black tea, the results were almost the 
same. This proves "there's something in black tea other than caffeine that 
protects me", said Dr Koh.

On the other hand, green tea had no observable effect on one's susceptibility 
to Parkinson's.

Echoing the findings of previous studies, smokers were also found to be less 
susceptible to Parkinson's because nicotine provides strong protection. But 
there were also 10,000 other carcinogens in cigarettes, added Dr Koh.

Responding to media queries, Dr Koh said the protective effect of black tea 
and caffeine functioned independently. 

A person who drinks black tea and coffee would have greater protection, 
compared to one who drinks only one of the beverages. 

When asked for a recommended level of intake, she said the study offered no 
absolute amounts, showing only "the pattern that higher caffeine content 
offers higher protection".

Of course everything must be done in moderation, she laughed: "Don't go 
drinking bucketfuls of tea." 

There are many Western studies on Parkinson's disease, but not enough with 
data on Asians. So, the Singapore finding aims to fill this gap, said Dr Koh.

Dr Tan said further studies would have to be conducted to test the results 
against the other races here. Previous researches had shown that the 
incidence of Parkinson's among the Chinese, Malays and Indians was similar.

The study will continue looking for other factors associated with the disease 
and the NNI will be looking into why black tea offers such protection. The 
goal is to develop drugs that prevent or reduce the development of 
Parkinson's, said Dr Tan.

There are 2,000 to 3,000 cases of Parkinson's here, with about 300 new ones 
recorded annually.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
To sign-off Parkinsn send a message to: mailto:[log in to unmask]
In the body of the message put: signoff parkinsn