Print

Print


I have had a terrible time trying to get my HMO to cover visits to a
Parkinson specialist.
I had been sent for diagnosis to an HMO approved neurologist by my primary
care physician.  It took 3 months of return visits before the neuro was able
to make a diagnosis of Parkinson's (his first diagnosis was carpal tunnel
syndrome).  He gave me misinformation (eg. an MRI would definitely show if I
had PD) and finally prescribed 15 mg of Permax as a beginning medication for
very mild PD (a very strange choice).  He also gave me no information at all
about PD and seemed annoyed when I questioned him.
Because of my negative experience with this general neurologist, I asked the
HMO for permission to visit a PD specialist for a second opinion, evaluation
and proper medication.  The HMO refused, even though my primary care
physician was extremely supportive of my request and I was suffering from
depression over the whole situation.
I went through three appeals - the last time meeting with a panel which
included the president of the HMO.  They continued to deny my request, but
said I could submit to to binding arbitration at $500 a day (my treat).
Instead I filed a complaint with the California Department of Corporations,
which is the regulating body for HMO's in CA, asking for reimbursement of my
initial visit to a PD specialist and coverage of future visits.  I am still
awaiting their answer.
In short, I have not had good luck with my HMO - which incidently was
recently given an A+ rating by our local newspaper in their recent ranking of
HMO's.
I feel it is important to see a PD specialist so I have been paying for my
visits out of pocket. It is infuriating to know how cold-hearted the health
care industry has become. In fact my last suggestion to the HMO was that they
replace the heart in their logo with a dollar sign.
Mary Sheehan
( 58 DX '96 )