It seems to me that the following points must by now be self evident: 1. Part of the list membership likes, and intends to continue with chat. 2. Part of the list membership hates, and intends to continue complaining about chat. 3. Most of the membership is getting sick and tired of the bickering. I would like to suggest a comprimise, which being that 1. The chatters show consideration for the anti-chatters by not pursuing a theme ad nausium. It would also be a positive contribution if a theme is dropped when it becomes obvious that it is becoming annoying. 2. the anti-chatters show consideration for the chatters by tolerating a reasonable number of exchanges. I am probably not alone in having at one time contributed to the chat, and at another wished that a particular thread of chat would go away and stay gone. As I am starting to see this debate as the longest chat theme yet, I shall make my personal contribution by making this my last word on the subject. Love you all, Dennis ++++++++++++++++++++ Dennis Greene 47/10 [log in to unmask] ++++++++++++++++++++