Print

Print


Debbie -

In a message dated 97-04-26 05:55:28 EDT, you write:

> She has no tremor at all
>except occasionally in that hand, but when it's in use. I know that the PD
>tremor is a resting one. Are there others with hardly any tremor but when
>they have it it's when it's in use??  Thanks.

You're right about the PD tremor being described as a "resting tremor."  What
you describe sounds more like essential tremor than Parkinson's.  Having
lived with Dick's PD for 15 years, and having worked for 5 years for a boss
with essential tremor, I have some experience with both.   In the case of my
boss, the harder he tried to control a pen, a cup of coffee, or whatever, the
more it shook.  I've never seen that in PD.

 My understanding is that if the PD meds work, then it's probably
Parkinson's, and if they don't, you should seek another diagnosis.   Some of
our helpful MDs on the list will probably respond more informatively than I
can.  I would just say that it's a good idea to have your mother evaluated by
a movement disorder specialist, as opposed to a GP or general neurologist.
 Some people with PD have spent years getting an accurate diagnosis - and
conversely, I imagine some people with other illnesses that include tremor
are incorrectly diagnosed as having PD.

Good luck.  Margie Swindler      [log in to unmask]