Print

Print


Whitie and John,

I wanted to get my 2 cents in regarding John's recommendation of
Breggin's book especially without balancing it out with Peter Kramer's
book "Listening to Prozac".  Peter Breggin has made a career (as a
psychiatrist) by bashing virtually every pharmacological advance in
psychiatry in the past 20 years. Read what he has to say but take it in
that context.  Kramer comes from the point of view of a psychotherapist
who discovered the value of antidepressants in by using them with his
patients.

PROZAC IS A GOOD DRUG BUT HAS NO PARTICULAR ADVANTAGE OVER OTHER ssri'S,
I prefer Zoloft and take it myself but different drugs in the same class
for some reason appear to be more effective or have different side
effect profiles in different individuals.  If one antidepressant fails
or is not tolerated it is reasonable to try another (carefully and with
a physician's supervision).

Good luck,

Charlie

John Morey wrote:
>
> At 06:38 AM 10/11/97 -0400, WHITIE wrote:
>
> >I am interested in hearing more about your success with PROZAC.
> >can you tell me how long it took to see results, and how much she
> >is taking ? I would like to look in to a change from the meds we are
> >using.  thanks   WHITIE
>
> Whitie, I went the other way, from Prozac to Welbutrin to Zoloft. A very
> good book to read on Prozac is "Talking back to Prozac" by Dr. Briggin, St.
> Martin Press, 1994.  Whether you agree with it or not, it has a lot of good
> information on neurological drugs and neurotransmitters.
>                                                                 Peace, John

--

CHARLES T. MEYER, M.D.
Middleton, WI
[log in to unmask]