Lawrence Yap's article is delightful: funny, passionate, well- written. Applying it? Well, not literally. Yes, what he is saying is "true". But he does not mean for it to be didactic. He scored by breaking the rules at the end of a course; I would hate to advise one of my students in a Writing Centre conference to take that chance. My student would surely get an F and say that I had encouraged him to do it that way! In my Effective Writing course, I encouraged students to break "rules" after they had learned to write within certain structures-- like improvisation in music. Yap obviously knows academia well enough to give himself the freedom to give it a blast. Good for him! But back to Margaret's question. I like to think that we Writing Centre people aren't selling out to the extent that we deserve to be stereotyped like Yap's unimaginative "advisor." Nevertheless, he does put the knife in, I have to admit: there you are, Roberta Lee, talking platitudes to those students, you who think you're above all that----ha ha. Supervisor, Writing Centre University of New Brunswick, Saint John P.O. Box 5050 Saint John, NB E2L 4L5 Fax: (506) 648-5528 Phone: (506) 648-5502 Email: [log in to unmask]