Print

Print


Dear Bill,
I believe we met at the Seattle Parkinson's symposium, which I enjoyed
very much. Wish I'd had more time to talk to individuals, it was a great
meeting!

> Also, does anyone have information on a vitamin regimen that is helpful to
> those with PD?

Unfortunately, nutrition is never that simple. It would be great to
advise everyone with PD to take 200-400 IUs of vitamin E, for instance.
However, some of my clients are using medications like aspirin or
coumadin, or have a family history of hemorrhagic stroke. Large amounts
of vit. E could potentially be fatal in some cases.

It used to be thought that older adults should have more iron, hence all
the Geritol ads. Now, though, iron is known to be an oxidant; people
over age 50 are advised not to use iron supplements unless they are
anemic.

Vitamin C is generally considered to be a useful vitamin without side
effects; however, it can increase iron absorption, and this often isn't
a good idea -- for instance, for some people with heart disease.

I ask my clients for a 3-day food record, which I analyze to get a
nutrient profile; also a medical history, and quite a bit of other
information. Following all this, I frequently do recommend vitamins
and/or minerals as an adjunct to various appropriate foods; but I'd
never make a blanket statement re supplementation -- it wouldn't be
professional.

Most often, I recommend a vitamin/mineral supplement that contains the
RDA for most major nutrients; plus a calcium supplement and/or fortified
foods, such as calcium-fortified orange juice. And often a B-complex.
But food is the gold standard when it comes to nutrients; supplements
are more like, well, copper or brass. Food supplies protective fiber
complexes as well as powerful flavonoids that supplements can't match.

Best regards,
Kathrynne

--
Kathrynne Holden, MS, RD
"Nutrition you can live with!"
Medical nutrition therapy
http://www.nutritionucanlivewith.com/
Tel: 970-493-6532 // Fax: 970-493-6538