Well the press did it again!! The story on sham surgery and featuring our own Ruth Ashley was reasonably done. Bob Bazell who had done the DATELINE story on the STN stimulation did this one also. Both the TV report ant the Wall Street Journal article reprinted on MSNBC web site at{ http://MSNBC.com/news/222719.asp } are reasonable and bring to light to the general public interesting and important issues in medical ethics. But I was horrified by the promos given for the segment earlier in the day and (I quote exactly from MSNBC Friday on NBC ‘Nightly News’ Imagine if you thought you were getting an operation that could save your life — major surgery — but later found out it was a sham, and the doctors knew about it all along. Tune in for our report. They present it like they are exposing a major medical fraud rather than an ethical debate, I am a participant in the Tampa (Dr. Freeman) surgery program and found everyone involved straightforward, informative and highly ethical. It is extremely stressful but we (My family and I ) went into my surgery eyes open and fully informed. If any other participants have had different experiences would like to hear about it. Charlie Charlie -- ****************************************************************************************** Charles T. Meyer, M.D. Middleton (Madison), Wisconsin [log in to unmask] ******************************************************************************************