Print

Print


E-literate patients upstage doctors

Thursday, September 16, 1999 Published at 23:20 GMT 00:20 UK - Patients are
upstaging their doctors using information they have picked up from the
Internet, according to a report.

It also suggests that the medium will transform health care, with doctors
and patients having less and less face to face contact.

And with the advent of videoconferencing and greater bandwidth - allowing
more information to travel along telephone lines faster - patients will be
able to benefit from specialist services not available locally.

However, both doctors and patients will need to revise their attitudes to
each other and learn new skills for the advances to be successful.

Writing in the British Medical Journal (BMJ), Alejandro Jadad of McMaster
University in Ontario said that thanks to the Internet, patients had access
to as much medical information as doctors.

Moreover, they were sharing their knowledge - meaning that, more than ever
before, patients and not doctors were responsible for the spread of
clinical facts.

"Even children can provide information to their peers, their parents,
clinicians and policymakers," he said.

"Some people even offer to do research on behalf of other patients for fees
that surpass those charged by clinicians for consultations."

This was leading to a change in the balance of power between doctors and
patients.

"It is evident that clinicians are finding themselves upstaged by and ill
prepared to cope with patients who bring along information downloaded from
the Internet," he said.

"We need to devote more resources to studying the implications of the
Internet for the the role of patients and the clinicians and to ensure the
clinician-patient relationship is strengthened rather than undermined."

The article was one of many looking at changes in the doctor-patient
relationship appearing in a special edition of the BMJ that claimed to mark
"the end of paternalism in the NHS".

Angela Coulter, executive director of policy and development at the King's
Fund and guest editor of the journal, agreed the Internet was changing the
doctor-patient relationship.

"A number of patients come in waving things they've picked up from the
Internet," she told BBC News Online.

"This is both a good and a bad thing - good because patients should be
informed but bad because there's a lot of unreliable information out there."

But she did not share Mr Jadad's concern that the balance of power might
shift too far, with patients upstaging doctors in their own surgeries.

"The balance of power needs to slip, because there's a paternalism in the
NHS and patients are treated like children. They're not - they're grown ups."

She said the best way to achieve a better balance was through doctors
improving their communications skills and patients getting reliable
information.


BBC News Home
<http://news.bbc.co.uk/low/english/health/newsid_449000/449566.stm>


janet paterson
52 now / 41 dx / 37 onset
613 256 8340 po box 171 almonte ontario canada K0A 1A0
a new voice: <http://www.geocities.com/SoHo/Village/6263/>
<[log in to unmask]>