Susan,'

You failed to say how large an area of roof is needed. I had my roof
replaced last year, and the cost was substantially less than the money you
are talking.  My house is a two story with approximately 2,500 sq ft of
total space.  The roof area is about 1500 sq ft as I remember.

You did not say where you live. The pitch of the roof makes a difference
too.  Snow areas require a greater pitch.  There is a greater need for
venting in the warmer climes,  The venting at the ridge pole is the best in
my area - I'm just on the south side [good side] of the Mason-Dixon.

You mentioned damage. Cedar shakes can be very good if there is a fairly
steep pitch and a disaster with a flatter roof. I presume the quotes
include repairing / replacing some sheathing, etc. With half or
three-quarter inch sheathing, staples are faster and do a good job. Some
craftsmen think they can do better with roofing nails.

The supervision on the job costs a bit extra. With a good roofer, the
supervisor is essence just collects his fee and does nothing.  With a green
crew or fast-buck/slap-dash workers, a supervisor can be very important.

Will Johnnston
A.P.D.A. DelMarVA Chapter Pres.
4049 Oakland School Road
Salisbury MD 21804 USA 410-543-0110



----------
From: Susan Trout <[log in to unmask]>
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: very Non-PD: roofing question;
Date: Friday, November 12, 1999 7:45 PM

Hi everyone,

I have a roofing question. We need to replace our 14+ year old cedar shake
roof and need to know what to look for in materials (composites, no more
cedar!) and the types of installation.

The roofing industry here is very unregulated compared to the rest of the
building trades. There are many kinds of installations using many differing
techniques and materials. Some do it as inexpensively as possible (like our
builder did, and it has caused damage to the house), and others do a
super-job.

Anyone know things like: roofing staples Vs roofing nails; where roof vents
are best placed, or, is it better to use ridge top venting along the entire
roof instead of vents? (We have square cap vents half way up/down the sides
of the roof.) One contractor said that unless the roof was vented along the
top ridge, the manufacturers would not guarantee the materials. Anyone
heard
of this?

 What should be looked for in a contractor, apart from licensing and
bonding? The ones in the 12-14G range all stipulate that the person doing
the estimates is on the job to supervise each day and the work is done
right. They also have up to 41 regular, long-time crews they work year
around...no really slow periods, and are booking now for spring
installations. They even go into detail as to the size and metal the
hammered-in nails are made of; the weight or mm of everything! The details
of some are amazing; others just say "here's the price" and can't, or
won't,
answer questions. The high-end ones are the one with photo albums of past
jobs, homes that can be seen, etc.

We have bids ranging $7,000 to $14,000 for a 25 year composite roof. The
higher end bids come from the contractors who are not strictly residential.
The $7,000 estimate came from an established home-roofing company, but they
declined to go up on the roof to examine the roof and rest of the house
structures which are affected by water and that can be seen from the roof
and not the ground.

The estimates which are in the $12,500-14,000 provide the most in details
for what removal and installation of the roof, quality of the materials &
workmanship, guarantees, details things needing to be done (include things
Not need doing), "what if" extra work is needed provisions, etc.

Any suggestions?